RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster

Experience authentic Italian cuisine at RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster in Brooklyn. Savor delicious dishes like oyster Rockefeller, fettuccine alfredo with shrimp, grilled skirt steak, and fresh calamari, complemented by refreshing margaritas and live music. Visit us at 1005 Surf Ave or call +1 917-924-1818 for a memorable dining experience!

Welcome to RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster

Taste the Difference.

RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster
RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster
RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster
RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster

Located at 1005 Surf Avenue, Brooklyn, RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster invites you to indulge in a fusion of Italian and seafood delights. This vibrant spot stands out for its warm ambiance and community spirit, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The tantalizing menu features a mouthwatering selection of steaks, lobsters, and Italian dishes, ensuring everyone finds something to savor. The combination of freshly sourced ingredients and expert cooking elevates every plate, while the friendly staff creates a welcoming atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back for more. Whether it's a romantic dinner or a lively group gathering, RARE offers the perfect setting for any occasion.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

1005 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, United States

Phone

+1 917-924-1818

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster
RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster
RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster
RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster

RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster stands as a culinary gem in Brooklyn, seamlessly blending Italian classics with delectable seafood offerings. The concept was born from a passion for food and service, and it resonates through every aspect of the restaurant. Known for its skirt steak salad and iconic steak and lobster combo, RARE satisfies various tastes and nutritional preferences. Dine on classic Italian pastas, or opt for the innovative lobster bisque or Spanish seafood paella—a favorite among locals seeking authenticity in every bite. The commitment to quality ingredients shines through, supported by a menu that frequently expands to incorporate seasonal specialties and community influences.

The restaurant encourages a jovial atmosphere where guests can enjoy each other's company while savoring substantial portions made with love. Community engagement is evident in events showcasing local musicians, creating a lively ambiance that enriches dining experiences. Saturdays can get packed, especially around peak dinner hours, so visiting during less busy times can offer a more relaxing experience. Whether you come for a special occasion or a casual night out, RARE embodies the inviting spirit of Brooklyn's culinary scene, bringing people together through shared passion for excellent food. On weeknights, it’s common to find families enjoying shared platters and friends laughing over well-crafted meals, as RARE has become a staple for gathering and celebration in the neighborhood.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday10 AM-12 AM
  • Monday10 AM-12 AM
  • Tuesday10 AM-12 AM
  • Wednesday10 AM-12 AM
  • Thursday10 AM-12 AM
  • Friday10 AM-12 AM
  • Saturday10 AM-12 AM

RARE excels in providing an exceptional dining experience, highlighted by live music that enhances the evening's vibe. The restaurant's menu boasts signature dishes, such as the succulent oyster Rockefeller and creamy fettuccine Alfredo, topped with shrimp. Guests rave about the perfectly cooked skirt steak and heavenly mashed potatoes, making each meal memorable. Don’t miss the refreshing margaritas, a local favorite that pairs ideally with the robust flavors of the seafood and steak options.

The restaurant accommodates both hearty eaters and lighter diners, with vegetarian selections and crispy calamari that appeal to diverse palates. Also, with an average price of just $17.73 across a whopping 196 menu items, RARE delivers great value without compromising quality.

RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster

The exterior of RARE Italy Restaurant Steak Lobster features a charming facade that reflects its Italian roots, catching the eye of passersby on Surf Avenue. The outdoor seating area allows diners to soak up the vibrant Brooklyn atmosphere, making it the perfect spot for people-watching. The setup provides a casual yet inviting vibe, with strings of lights adding a warm glow during evening hours. Community members often gather outside, showcasing RARE as a place where friends meet and conversations flourish—the ideal backdrop for enjoying delightful eats on a sunny afternoon.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

We went to this restaurant and were greeted with a warm and homely environment the service was very good and friendly. The interior is beautiful, and the food is even better. We ate a variety of things on the menu (muscles, steak, crab cakes, calamari, salads and more) we would like to have eaten more but we couldn't eat anymore! Come here and bring your friends.

A
Anna Y.

I just love it. Just so happen to hang with my son,his wife and my grands. We were deciding where to eat. I was really not feeling any restaurant cause you spend alot of money with the prices going and the food is nasty. Just horrible. We took a chance never been to Rare Steak and Lobster restaurant but went. I order Lobster Bisque Soup, and Fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp when my soup arrive i taste it i was finish it was excellent i mean it was absolutely, phenomenal this was the best bisque soup i have taste. I didnt even my shirmp fettuccine i had my son taste it.. We all enjoy the food i even order another Bisque lobster soup to take home. I told my coworkers that i finally got me a restaurant Food is good reasonable price. After work i went back order three bisque soup for myself and my coworker they love it . Thank you I even got half lobster excellent.i told my son i went he laugh. Finally great food .

G
Gail M.

We've visited this place many times with friends and we absolutely love it. Every dish we've tried has been delicious. This neighborhood truly needed a spot where you can enjoy a variety of cuisines in one place. I'm really surprised by the negative reviews, because everything we've had has been top-notch. The chef does an excellent job.

O
Olya M.

Wow! Amazing! The portions are HUGE! I got the skirt steak and it was enough for four. It came with potatoes and vegetables. The grilled flavor in the steak can't be beat. We also got the NY steak. Also huge and cooked to perfection. The oyster Rockefeller were the best I have ever had. My new Brooklyn favorite!

F
Frank M.

I already third time coming to this place , and it is always perfect , and fresh , you will be happy , and full for sure

R
Ruslan M.

Food excellent especially the steak, waitress very friendly and always taking care of our table, vibes really good for a date or even with family, definitely will come again.

C
Carlos S.